Sabrina gets approved for an Other Realm credit card and as a result, goes overboard buying things and becomes spoiled rotten. When Hilda and Zelda see how much stuff she bought, they order her to donate everything to a rummage sale to benefit the orphans in Honduras. However, Sabrina gives away her aunts' unwanted magical items instead, and as a result, her friends buy and fall victim to the items' magical powers. Meanwhile, Salem wants to get a pet of his own.