The Islanders spend the night getting to know their two new boys with risque dares, delicious chocolates, and extravagant pillow fights. Due to an unexpected loss at home, Josh makes the decision to leave The Villa and Shannon goes with him. Charlie expresses interest in Alana and is happy to hear his feelings are reciprocated. K-Ci and Andre get to take their girl of their choice out on a date. Sparks fly between Olivia and Andre unbeknownst to Korey who hopes he won't lose Bailey to an eagerly awaiting Jeremy.